The Truth About Color and Car Insurance: Does It Really Matter?

When buying a new car, color is often one of the most significant decisions. Many car buyers have heard rumors that specific colors, like red or black, might increase their insurance premiums. But how much truth is there to this? Does the color of your automobile impact the cost of insurance? For clarification, let's examine this widely held belief and clarify why you ought to get in touch with your insurance company. 

1. Myth Busting

Despite what many people think, your insurance premium is not directly impacted by the color of your automobile. Insurance companies are primarily interested in variables such as car age, make, model, body style, engine size, age, and driving record that impact risk or the expense of a claim. 

2. What Matters: The Vehicle's Make and Model

The make and model of your car play a much more significant role in determining your insurance rates. High-performance vehicles or cars that are more expensive to repair can increase premiums. Insurers consider the statistical data on the performance and claim history of these vehicle types.

3. Consider the Visibility Factor

While color does not directly influence insurance calculations, specific car colors are statistically more or less visible on the road, which could influence accident rates. Lighter colors, like white, tend to be involved in fewer accidents at dawn and dusk than darker colors. Discussing how visibility might affect safety can be a point to raise with your insurer.

4. Theft Rates by Car Type, Not Color

Thieves tend to target specific car models rather than their colors. If your vehicle model is a popular target for theft, it might carry higher insurance costs. Checking the theft rate for your car's make and model with your insurance provider can provide valuable insights.

5. Resale Value and Car Color

Specific colors have better resale value, and while this doesn't affect insurance, it's an interesting fact to consider when purchasing a car. More popular colors might be easier to sell on.

6. Personal Preferences and Trends

Car color can reflect personal tastes and trends, which can shift over time. If you're curious about how these trends affect other financial aspects of owning a car, your insurance agent might have interesting data to share.

7. Repair Costs and Paint Jobs

Specialty paints and finishes can be more expensive to repair. If your insurer considers the cost of potential repairs, this could affect your rates. For instance, a pearlescent finish might increase repair costs compared to standard paint.

8. The Psychological Impact of Color

Lastly, while not directly related to insurance, the color of your car might affect how you drive. Some studies suggest that color can influence driver behavior, although this is more psychological and less about concrete insurance realities.

In conclusion, while the color of your car makes a fabulous style statement, it doesn't impact your insurance premiums. Factors like car make, model, usage, driving history, and where you live play far more substantial roles in determining how much you pay. Understanding the various factors that affect your insurance premiums can help you make better decisions when buying a car and shopping for insurance.

Recent Posts

Business Interruption Insurance in 2026: How to Keep Cash Flow Alive When Operations Stop!

Running a business in 2026 means you’re juggling more moving parts than ever—supply chains, staff, cyber risks, weather events, and shifting customer habits. Most owners focus on protecting buildings, equipment, and vehicles, but the real stress often starts when the income stops while the bills keep coming.  1. Picture the ‘what if’ Starting with what […]

Read More
Emergency Funds vs. Insurance: What to Pay Out of Pocket and What to Insure Against!

When life throws a curveball, most of us wonder the same thing: should I pay for this from my savings, or is this what insurance is for? Balancing an emergency fund with the right coverage can feel confusing, but understanding the difference between “pay out of pocket” and “insure against” can bring real peace of […]

Read More
Restaurant, Retail or Contractor? Industry‑Specific Business Insurance Pitfalls to Avoid in 2026!

Running a business in 2026 is challenging enough without worrying whether your insurance will really help when you need it. If you own a restaurant, retail shop, or contracting business, the risks you face look very different, even if the policy documents sound similar. Understanding a few common pitfalls can help you talk with your […]

Read More
Bundle Your Policies or Keep Them Separate? The Guide to Saving on Insurance the Smart Way!

Insurance can feel like one of those chores you just have to “set and forget,” but the way you organize your policies can quietly shape your budget and peace of mind. Many companies offer a break on your premium when you bundle, but separating coverage can sometimes make more sense. The key is knowing how […]

Read More
Hecht-Stout Insurance Agency Dunlap, IL
We extend coverage to individuals and businesses in Dunlap, IL and surrounding areas.
1715 Woodside Drive Dunlap, IL 61525
reports@hechtstout.com
309-693-3388
© 2026 Hecht-Stout Insurance Agency Designed by Amplispot
Skip to content